IM FALLING IN LOVE WITH TWO PEOPLE.?

WELL, I AM CURRENTLY DATING TWO GUYS. THEY ARE SIMILAR IN A LOT OF WAYS. THEY ARE THEY SAME AGE.(25, IM 20). THEY BOTH HAVE TWO CHILDREN (I HAVE NONE), AND THEY BOTH ARE ECONOMICALLY STABLE. THE FIRST ONE IS A LOT MORE CARING. I CAN TELL THAT HE REALLY WANTS A RELATIONSHIP AND I NO HE WOULD BE A PERFECT FUTURE HUSBAND. HE HAS CUSTODY OF BOTH HIS CHILDREN THOU, AND IS KINDA LOOKING FOR A MOTHER TO THEM. (WOW). ALSO WE BUMP HEADS AND CANT SEEM TO ALWAYS GET ALONG. THE SECOND ONE HAS HIMSELF MORE TOGETHER THAN THEY FIRST, IN MY OPINION. WE COMMUINCATE WELL, WE NEVER ARGUE AND WE TELL EACH OTHER EVERYTHING. BUT HE DOES HAVE A LOT OF FEMALE FRIENDS AND IS VERY PROMISCUOUS. EVEN THOU HES KINDA A , HE HAS HAD RELATIONSHIPS WERE HE DID NOT CHEAT AND I FEEL WE CONNECT ENOUGH TO BE MEANINGFUL TO ONE ANOTHER. THEY HAVE GOOD AND BAD QUALITIES AND ITS HARD BECAUSE IM FALLING HEAD OVER HILLS FOR BOTH OF THEM. I EVEN MEANT THEM BOTH THE SAME DAY. WHAT SHOULD I DO?